Most Controversial Picks on this Website in Sports

Don't agree with the list? Place your vote or if you are a logged in, add a new item for others to vote on.

Vote for Pele named the most overrated athlete 1) Pele named the most overrated athlete

“Pele is not overrated. Soccer is a sport and Pele dominated at it. That was just a list made by a jealous person that is jealous of those athletes because they are great.”

Vote for Carlton Fisk in the Top 10 2) Carlton Fisk in the Top 10

“Carlton Fisk is ranked #10 on the list of Greatest Major League Hitters ever. Batted. 269 in his career and Ted Williams and WIllie Mays are not even on the list. Terrible pick Fisk is not one of the best hitters of all time.”

Vote for Adrian Peterson ranked #6 on the greatest running back lists 3) Adrian Peterson ranked #6 on the greatest running back lists

“Adrian Peterson has only played one season. In about 5 years he will be top ten, but it is too early to put him up there.”

Vote for Craig Biggio named the fourth best baseball player 4) Craig Biggio named the fourth best baseball player

“Biggio was named the 4th best player of all time. Players behind him: Barry Bonds, Honus Wagner, Walter Johnson, and many others.”

Vote for Patriots of the 21st century named best dynasty 5) Patriots of the 21st century named best dynasty

“The Patriots were named the best dynasty of all time. What about the Yankees, Celtics, and the Montreal Canadians”

Vote for Jets ranked #18 in all time sports upsets 6) Jets ranked #18 in all time sports upsets

“On the list of all time sports upsets the Jets over the Colts is ranked #18. When the Jets won it changed football forever.”

Vote for Notre dame not ranked number one 7) Notre dame not ranked number one

“On the greatest college football program list Oklahoma is #1 and Ohio State is #2. At #3 is Notre Dame, the teams that has won the most championships.”

Vote for Nolan Ryan named the best pitcher ever 8) Nolan Ryan named the best pitcher ever

“Nolan Ryan was named the #1 pitcher ever on the greatest pitchers ever list. There are several pitchers better than him.”

Vote for 2007 Patriots named the second best team of all time 9) 2007 Patriots named the second best team of all time

“In the list of the Top NFL team of all time the 2007 Patriots are ranked second. However they didn’t win the Super Bowl and the teams that did should be ranked ahead of them.”

Vote for Brady Quinn over Otto Graham 10) Brady Quinn over Otto Graham

“In the list best NFL quarterbacks Brady Quinn is ranked 14th and Otto Graham is ranked 19th.”